What to Expect When You Hire a Theft Defense Service

Your First Consultation with a Theft Defense Service

The journey begins with a consultation. This initial meeting is critical—it’s where we learn about your case and start mapping out a potential path forward.

• We ask questions about the charges, the events that led up to them, and any prior legal history.
  
  
• We explain your rights in simple terms.
  
  
• We discuss possible outcomes based on the facts you share.
  
  

Our job in this first phase is to listen and build trust. We know how important it is for you to feel heard and understood. After this meeting, you’ll have a better idea of what to expect and how we plan to help.

Understanding the Legal Framework: The Foundation of the Theft Defense Process

Before diving into strategy, we take time to explain the legal landscape you’re facing. Theft charges in Indiana can vary widely, and so can the penalties.

Here’s a simplified breakdown of theft classifications:

• Petty Theft: Usually under a certain dollar amount, often charged as a misdemeanor.
  
  
• Grand Theft: Higher value, typically a felony.
  
  
• Burglary or Robbery: Often includes force or unlawful entry, resulting in more serious consequences.
  
  

We make sure you understand the specifics of your charge and what it means for your future. Knowing the stakes early helps us—and you—make informed decisions.

Building a Strong Case: Inside the Theft Defense Process

Once you’ve hired us, we get to work immediately. Our defense strategy revolves around evidence, preparation, and protecting your rights at every turn. Here's what this phase looks like:

• Reviewing Discovery: We examine police reports, surveillance footage, witness statements, and any other materials the prosecution has.
  
  
• Identifying Weaknesses: We look for inconsistencies, procedural errors, or gaps in the prosecution’s evidence.
  
  
• Developing a Strategy: This could include disputing intent, negotiating reduced charges, or preparing for trial.
  
  

We tailor our strategy to your specific situation. There’s no one-size-fits-all approach in criminal defense. That’s why how a theft defense attorney works behind the scenes is so important—it’s all about details, timing, and smart decisions.

Open communication is part of what sets our theft defense service apart. You’ll never feel left in the dark about your case. We provide regular updates, and we’re always available to answer questions.

We explain every step before we take it. This includes:

• Court filing deadlines
  
  
• Motions we submit
  
  
• Meetings with the prosecutor
  
  
• Expected timelines for each phase
  
  

We believe transparency builds confidence. When you understand what’s happening and why, you can be a more informed participant in your own defense.

Pre-Trial Options: How We Navigate the Early Phases of a Theft Defense Process

In many cases, there are opportunities to resolve theft charges before going to trial. We explore every legal tool at our disposal.

Some options include:

• Diversion Programs: These may allow for charges to be dismissed after completion of certain requirements.
  
  
• Plea Negotiations: We work with the prosecution to reduce charges or sentencing in exchange for a guilty plea.
  
  
• Motions to Dismiss: If there are flaws in the evidence or violations of your rights, we may ask the court to dismiss the charges altogether.
  
  

These tools can be powerful in protecting your record and minimizing the long-term impact of a charge. We approach each with care and a clear explanation of the risks and benefits.

Court Appearances and Representation by a Theft Defense Attorney

If your case goes to court, rest assured—we’re with you at every hearing. Here’s what our courtroom support looks like:

• We arrive early, prepared with documents, arguments, and a defense plan.
  
  
• We speak on your behalf whenever possible to reduce your stress and potential missteps.
  
  
• We ensure your rights are protected throughout cross-examination and testimony.
  
  

Our courtroom presence is calm, confident, and backed by deep knowledge of theft laws in Indiana. That’s the value of working with a seasoned theft defense attorney—you’re never navigating court alone

Defense Strategies: How a Theft Defense Attorney Works to Protect Your Reputation

Every case has a story. Our job is to help the court hear yours.

We use various defense strategies depending on your situation. These may include:

• Lack of Intent: You didn’t mean to steal or believed the property was yours.
  
  
• Mistaken Identity: Someone else committed the crime, and you were wrongly accused.
  
  
• Consent: You had permission to take or use the item in question.
  
  
• Illegal Search and Seizure: Your rights were violated during arrest or investigation.
  
  

Each of these strategies requires detailed preparation. We gather witness testimony, expert analysis, and supporting documents to present a complete picture.

Understanding the Outcome: How the Theft Defense Process Wraps Up

Once the case is resolved, whether through a trial verdict or plea agreement, we stay with you to explain the next steps. Outcomes can vary widely, so it’s important to understand what comes after.

Possible resolutions include:

• Acquittal: A not-guilty verdict means you’re cleared of all charges.
  
  
• Probation: A period of supervision instead of jail time.
  
  
• Fines or Restitution: Financial payments to victims or the court.
  
  
• Jail or Prison Time: For more serious offenses or prior convictions.
  
  

No matter the outcome, we’re here to support you with appeals (if needed), record expungement options, or advice on how to move forward.

Life After the Case: Support Beyond the Theft Defense Process

The end of a case doesn’t mean the end of our relationship. At Collins & Associates, we stay invested in your long-term success.

Here’s how we continue to support our clients:

• Guidance on job applications or background checks
  
  
• Help with clearing or sealing criminal records
  
  
• Referrals to counseling or rehabilitation programs (if needed)
  
  
• Advice on rights restoration
  
  

We understand the stigma a theft charge can carry. Our mission goes beyond defense—it’s about helping you rebuild, recover, and move forward with confidence.

Why You Can Trust a Theft Defense Service Like Ours

Hiring a theft defense service is about more than legal representation. It’s about finding a team that listens, explains, defends, and stands by you. At Collins & Associates, we take pride in protecting our clients and guiding them through each step of the theft defense process with skill and compassion.

You now have a clearer understanding of how a theft defense attorney works, what to expect in court, and how we approach every aspect of your defense. From the moment you call to the final outcome, we are committed to protecting your name, your freedom, and your future.

Need Legal Help Today?



Reach out to us at Collins & Associates for a confidential consultation. Call us at 812-475-1234 or email rich@collins-law.com to learn more. We’re here when you need us most.

Frequently Asked Questions